Lengthy and uneven but occasionally fun

Peak 90’s action

Adequate but overindulgent

A misstep in the career of the beloved fantasy auteur

A respectful if lackluster legacy sequel

Action packed and bloody

A subpar sequel to a mediocre legacy sequel

B-movie material with A+ budget

Simply awful

A mediocre sequel of a horror classic

The Wicker Man this is not

A spectacular misfire of a horror film

Gonzo but unfrightening giallo tribute

Underwhelming collaboration between Depp and Polanski

Epic and tense war film

Tense and solid

Visually inspiring but emotionally empty

Formulaic but fun

Disappointing Hollywood debut

A monumental experience