Slick, fun and soulless

Best sci-fi horror since “Alien” (1979)

An exhilarating action masterpiece

Ambitious, flimsy and telegraphic

Visceral, visually stunning neo-noir

Adequate but overindulgent

A misstep in the career of the beloved fantasy auteur

A respectful if lackluster legacy sequel

Action packed and bloody

A subpar sequel to a mediocre legacy sequel

B-movie material with A+ budget

Simply awful

A mediocre sequel of a horror classic

The Wicker Man this is not

A spectacular misfire of a horror film

Gonzo but unfrightening giallo tribute

Underwhelming collaboration between Depp and Polanski

Tense and solid

Visually inspiring but emotionally empty

Formulaic but fun